Physics of punching

In the late 1970s, when Feld was earning a brown belt in karate, his instructor, Ronald McNair, also happened to be his physics student. (McNair later died tragically while working as a scientist-astronaut aboard Space Shuttle Challenger.) The secret to karate, both men agreed, lies in the speed and exceptional focus of the strike. But just how fast does a karate punch move? To find out, they joined with undergraduate Stephen Wilk and set up a strobe light that flashed either 60 or 120 times per second. Then they photographed McNair and others throwing various kicks and punches. Once the film was developed, they could calculate the speed of a punch by counting how many times the strobe flashed until the fist hit its target.

Feld and McNair found that beginning students can throw a karate chop at about 20 feet per second–just enough to break a one-inch board. But a black belt like McNair could chop at 46 feet per second. At that speed, a 1 1/2-pound hand can deliver a wallop of up to 2,800 newtons (one newton is roughly equal to the force exerted by the weight of an apple). Splitting a typical concrete slab 1 1/2 inches thick takes on average only 1,900 newtons.

Of course, the best boxers can punch as quickly and powerfully as any black belt. Why can’t they break concrete blocks too? The answer lies in the nature of their punches. When a boxer throws his fist, he usually ends the movement with follow-through. This gives the punch maximum momentum (golf and tennis players follow through for the same reason), and it can help knock an opponent down. But the impact itself is diffuse: It’s meant to jar an opponent’s brain, not crack his skull.

A karate chop, on the other hand, has no follow-through at all: It lashes out like a cobra and then withdraws instantly When a black belt hits a slab of concrete, for instance, his fist touches the block for fewer than five milliseconds, and yet the block breaks with a resounding crack.

To understand how this works, Jearl Walker, a former tae kwon do student who now teaches physics at Cleveland State University, set up a study much like Feld’s and McNair’s. A well-thrown fist, he found, reaches its maximum velocity when the arm is about 80 percent extended. “That’s exactly what my tae kwon do master had taught me,” Walker says. “You learn to focus your punch in your imagination so that it terminates inside your opponent’s body, rather than on the surface. To deliver the maximum power, you want to make contact before the slowdown begins.”

The purpose of all that focused power is brutally obvious: to break bones and rupture tissue. But success also depends on more subtle forces. Solid as they seem, all materials are at least slightly elastic. Whack them in the right spot and they will start to oscillate. A punch with a follow-through would dampen such oscillations, but a karate chop, by pulling away at the last moment, lets them move freely “If you tweak a rubber band it goes up and down, and the same is true if you tweak a board or a brick with a much greater force,” Feld says. “When they reach their elastic limits, they start to yield. In other words, they break.”

Fortunately for most of us, reaching that limit in bones is no easy matter. Feld says bone can withstand 40 times more force than concrete, and a cylinder of bone less than an inch in diameter and 2 1/3 inches long can withstand a force of more than 25,000 newtons. Hands and feet can withstand even more than that, because their skin, muscles, ligaments, tendons, and cartilage absorb a great deal of impact. As a result, a well-kicked foot can absorb about 2,000 times as much force as concrete before breaking.


About arnulfo

veterano del ciberespacio
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Physics of punching

  1. Robert says:

    Your initial math is wrong, a 1kg hand, traveling 14 m/s^2 is only 14N, not 2,000. How did you get those numbers?

      • Karl says:

        The reason you’re getting such low numbers is because you aren’t taking into account the full amount of weight behind a punch. A trained fighter will punch through a transfer of energy, starting with the feet, moving into the legs, then with a rotation of the hips, then the chest, then the arms and then finally the fist. This way you are able to get very close to the full weight of your body into a punch and dramatically increase its force compared to somebody isolating their fist or hand to punch.

      • arnulfo says:

        all that affects the applied force but is not straightforward how all that links with the speed of the punch

      • Dorian says:

        Speed of the punch doesn’t effect force, acceleration does. If I can accelerate my weight at 14m/s^2 for a fraction of a second, I will exert 14*(my weight) newtons of force. I might not reach 14m/s^2, because I wasn’t accelerating for a full second, but that doesn’t change my force exerted. At that acceleration, 140 kg person could exert 2000 n of force. For a more average sized person, we are missing half our force. Something is up here.

      • arnulfo says:

        speed affect the momentum transfer at the point of impact

  2. Pingback: 2010 in review | The grokking eagle

  3. lorn says:

    Most punch is measured in pounds. I do not understand why that is. How do u convert force in weight?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s